Some U.S. Machine Cancellations

September 7, 2009

Also try Pick-a-Picture!
[NOTE: lots of pictures on that page.]

Here are some examples of machine cancellations from the United States. The images are of items that used to be in my collection, and are for the most part from the early part of the 20th Century. Early in this century, the United States Post Office was trying to find the best cancelling machine to use, and therefore experimented with a large variety of them from many manufacturers. We machine cancel collectors have a wonderful time studying this fascinating variety of markings. Note that the Machine Cancel Society has its own web site!

American Flag Cancellation

The markings of the American Postal Machine Company are first found from the Boston area in 1884. They adopted the well-known flag killer in 1894. Machines with the flag cancellation were still in use during the WW II era. Since there were so many different machines and towns using them, they have become a popular collecting specialty. A typical American flag cancellation [7k GIF].

American Non-Flag Cancellation

The markings of the American Postal Machine Company are first found from the Boston area in 1884. They adopted the well-known flag killer in 1894. However, from about 1909 to about 1920, some of the American machines used a 6-bar straight-line killer. These are not nearly as common as the flag cancellations. A 6-bar straight-line American cancellation [3k GIF].

Time Marking/Cummins Cancellation

The cancellations of the Time Marking Machine Company (later taken over by the B. F. Cummins Company) first appear around 1905, and continued in use for at least 2 decades. When the earlier machines were working correctly, they impressed the exact minute of cancellation, as this example [5k GIF] demonstrates. Here is an example of the type J machine [4k GIF].

Barry Machine Cancellation

The Barry Postal Supply Company of Oswego, New York created machines that impressed a wide variety of postmarks. They are seen primarily between the years 1895 and 1909. Barry was an inventor by trade, and held many patents on many devices. The postal cancellation machines were only part of his business. The Barry cancellations come in a wide variety of styles, and were used in many cities and towns in the early part of the 20th Century. Here we have two Barry types, a circular cancel [5k GIF] and an oval cancel [4k GIF]. There were more types than these.

Doremus Machine Cancellation

Doremus machine markings started to appear in 1899, and continued until after WW I in a few locations. These machine markings got me started collecting machine cancellations, as they are quite distinct. Here we have a so-called type "E" cancel [7k GIF], a type "F" cancel [5k GIF], an early type "A" cancel [4k GIF], and a type "C" cancel [5k GIF]. As with other machines, other types exist than these.

Barr-Fyke Machine Cancellation

The Barr-Fyke Machine Company of Kansas City, Missouri made a small number of machines. These cancellations appear from about 1897 to about 1905. They are very distinctive, and are not common. Here is one type of the Barr-Fyke cancellation [5k GIF], another early type with 7 bars [4k GIF], and another with arcs in the dial [5k GIF]. The last example is the rare 8-bar Barr-Fyke machine [4k GIF].

Whitehead Machine Cancellation

The Whitehead machine, invented in Brooklyn, New York, actually cut into the stamp, along with cancelling it with ink. Whitehead's machine also backstamped mail, but did not use the cutters for this process. These machines appear to have only been used in Brooklyn, New York between 1898 and 1900. They are rare. This example is a backstamp usage [4k GIF].

Pneumatic Machine Cancellation

The Pneumatic Cancelling Machine Company of Indianapolis, Indiana produced machines used from about 1898 to about 1904. The impressions from these machines are quite distinct from other machines of the time. They are somewhat common from Indianapolis, but less so from the few other cities where they were used. This example is from Helena, Montana [4k GIF].

Hampden Machine Cancellation

These cancellations were made by machines of The Hampden Cancelling Machine Company of Holyoke, Massachusetts. Such machines were in use from about 1898 to about 1905. They are not particularly common. While the styles of the bars and postmark varied, this is a typical example [3k GIF].

Tilton Cancellation

These cancellations were made by a device that can more correctly be described as a mechanical stamping device. This is distinct from a machine canceller, which includes some automatic feeding system. This device, as well as the Perfection device, were mechanisms that only assisted the stamping of the cancellation. The operator had to place the item under the canceller, before activating the mechanical "arm".

These cancellations are, however, fascinating in their own right, since they marked mail that had been delivered late from the incoming trains. This type of marking allowed the Post Office customer to know why their mail had arrived late. The Post Office prided itself on overnight delivery by rail, between major cities, such as Chicago and New York. These stamping devices were in use in New York City from 1882 to about 1890 (and then later in Buffalo, New York). This marking is from typical late-arriving mail [7k GIF].

International Machine Cancellation

These cancellations are very common, and are immediately recognizable to many people as "machine cancellations". After all the various experimentation on the part of the Post Office, the government settled on large orders of machines from the International Postal Supply Company. This company's postmarks appear as early as 1888, and appear to this day. There are many, many varieties of postmarks made by this company's machines, but here is an early International machine with a small dial [3k GIF] and a more recognizable later type [7k GIF]. Here is Another International example from Flickr, and another International cancel from Flickr.

Columbia Machine Cancellation

The Columbia Postal Supply Company of Silver Creek, New York produced a variety of machines. These impressions can be quite common, but there are also some scarce examples. The first machines were in use around 1900, and continued in use for several decades. Most of the Columbia cancellations are quite unique.

Here is an early Columbia machine type [3k GIF] that could easily be mistaken for other machines in use during the time period. Another Columbia cancel with 7 bars in the killer [4k GIF].

Universal Machine Cancellation

These cancellations, like those from the International machines, are very common, and are immediately recognizable to many people as "machine cancellations". Machines made by the Universal Stamping Machine Company of New York first appear in 1909, and various models were in use for many, many years. About 1920, Universal was taken over by the Pitney-Bowes organization, but Universal machines remain on the market to this day. Here is an early Universal machine type [3k GIF] and a more common, later Universal type [4k GIF]. Here is an example of a Universal cancel from Flickr.

The End (For Now)

Well, it has been fun for me to put this page together. I hope that you have learned more about the fascinating hobby of collecting machine cancellations. This is just a quick survey; there were other machine manufacturers in the U.S. over the 20th Century, as well as a great variety of cancelling machines manufactured and used throughout the world.

The Machine Cancel Society

For further reference, you can purchase many books from the Machine Cancel Society. These books describe and catalog these illustrated (and other) machine cancellations. In particular, look for U. S. Machine Postmarks 1871-1925 by the late R. F. Hanmer. This book provides the best overview on the subject, and, frankly, I used a lot of the information from this excellent book to generate this Web page.